When the show strays from our assumptions (by sending queens home too early or too late) or queens exhibit behavior that contradicts this clandestine, infallible ranking system, the fandom reacts poorly. We, the audience, have preconceived notions of each queen’s skills and strengths, and we therefore create an unofficial “pecking order” that we assume must and will be followed. Part of the reason is that the cast, seasoned Drag Race alumni, come in with reputations. Not just this season, which had big shoes to fill after the compelling, well-received, and satisfying season 12, but every All Stars installation.
All Stars has and always will be a tricky beast.